When I first opened Urban Betty in 2005, my hiring strategy was pretty simple. I needed warm bodies. 😂

Seriously. I had six booth rental chairs, a mountain of bills, and absolutely no idea how to build a team. If someone wanted to rent a chair and could pay me $200 a week, great! Welcome to Urban Betty.

There wasn’t a formal interview process, a personality assessment, or even much consideration about whether someone would fit into the culture I wanted to create. At that point, I didn’t even know what salon culture meant. I was just trying to keep my business afloat.

Fast forward more than 20 years, and Urban Betty has grown into a multimillion-dollar salon company with three locations and nearly 100 team members. We’ve had employees stay with us for 15, 17, and even 20 years. And let me tell you, I’ve learned a LOT about hiring along the way.

But here’s what might surprise you. The qualities I look for in a great long-term team member have very little to do with how talented they are behind the chair.

You can teach someone how to cut hair, formulate color, or do a beautiful blowout. What matters just as much, and sometimes more, is how that person shows up, connects with others, handles challenges, and responds when things don’t go their way.

And after hundreds of interviews and plenty of expensive mistakes, I’ve narrowed it down to four green flags that I pay close attention to.

 

1. They Present Themselves Professionally

We’re in the beauty industry. Our guests come to us because they want to look and feel their best, and whether we like it or not, how we present ourselves influences how much confidence someone has in our ability to help them do that.

Now, I’m not saying everyone needs to wear designer clothing, have a full face of makeup, or look exactly the same. Absolutely not. I love individuality, and I think personal style is part of what makes our industry so fun. You can look casual and still look incredibly professional.

For me, it’s about being intentional with your appearance. Is your hair styled? Do you look put together? Are you presenting yourself in a way that inspires confidence? Our guests are trusting us with their appearance, and I want them to feel comfortable putting that trust in our hands.

I always laugh because some people look amazing without a stitch of makeup. I am NOT one of those people. 😂 But that’s not the point. It’s about knowing how to present yourself professionally in a way that feels authentic to you.

And this starts before someone ever walks through our doors. We’ve moved a lot of our initial interviews to Zoom, which has made the hiring process easier for everyone. But here’s something I wish more people understood. A Zoom interview is still an interview!

I’ve had candidates look fantastic on paper and then show up to a Zoom call like they’re casually FaceTiming a friend. I’ve also had people make an incredible first impression online and then show up to their in-person interview looking like they put in half the effort.

That inconsistency tells me something.

Of course, you can’t know everything about someone from one or two interviews. I’ve learned that sometimes you don’t really see how someone consistently shows up until they’ve been working with you for several months. But those first impressions are still an opportunity to understand how seriously they take their professional responsibilities.

 

2. They Show Up Early and Prepared

My husband will tell you that I am annoyingly early for EVERYTHING. 😂

I don’t like rushing into situations. I want time to get settled, look around, understand what’s happening, and mentally prepare myself. I’ve noticed that I’m much more confident and successful when I’ve had a few minutes to acclimate to my environment.

And I look for that same sense of preparation in the people we hire.

If you have a 9:00 appointment, showing up at 8:55 might give you enough time to physically set up your station, but are you actually prepared to give that guest your full attention? Have you looked at their appointment history? Do you know what services they’re receiving? Are you mentally ready to start your day?

I think those things matter.

And punctuality is especially important in the salon industry because our entire business revolves around appointments. We’re seeing guests back to back, and one stylist running behind can affect the entire day.

If a guest is consistently kept waiting, eventually they’re going to stop coming back. And considering how much money we invest in marketing and bringing new guests through our doors, that’s not something I’m willing to overlook.

We’ve had employees who struggled with chronic lateness over the years. And believe me, we understand that life happens. People have kids, emergencies, health issues, and circumstances that occasionally make it difficult to be on time. We’re human, and we work with people when situations come up.

But there’s a big difference between occasionally running late and consistently disregarding your schedule and the guests who are depending on you.

When lateness becomes an ongoing problem that coaching and accountability don’t resolve, sometimes we have to make the difficult decision to let someone go. Or, as we like to say at Urban Betty, release them to the industry.

The point isn’t that someone needs to be perfect. It’s that their actions should demonstrate respect for their guests, their coworkers, and the business.

 

3. They Aren’t Afraid to Ask Questions

This is one of my favorite green flags, partly because it’s something I’ve personally struggled with for most of my life.

Growing up, I didn’t always feel comfortable asking questions. I came from a household where kids were expected to be seen and not heard, and over time I developed the habit of figuring everything out on my own.

And while that independence has certainly helped me as an entrepreneur, it has also made things harder than they needed to be.

I can sit through an entire meeting, absorb all the information, and then think of 20 questions after everyone has left. Meanwhile, there’s always that one person who’s asking thoughtful questions throughout the conversation, getting clarification, and actually understanding what needs to happen next.

I’m genuinely jealous of those people sometimes!

When I’m interviewing someone, I love when they’re curious. I love when they ask how things work, why we do things a certain way, what opportunities are available, and how they can continue growing.

To me, that shows someone who’s interested in understanding the bigger picture rather than just showing up and collecting a paycheck.

And I’ve noticed something over the years. The people who are willing to ask questions often get to the answers faster because they’re making decisions based on actual information instead of assumptions.

That doesn’t mean someone needs to ask their manager a million questions every day. There’s absolutely value in being resourceful, researching things independently, and trying to find solutions on your own.

But there’s a huge difference between someone who’s curious and resourceful and someone who thinks they already know everything.

The latter can be incredibly difficult to coach because they aren’t necessarily interested in learning another way of doing things.

Curiosity is one of the clearest signs that someone has room to grow. And people who want to grow are exactly the kind of people I want on my team.

4. They Can Receive Feedback Without Taking Everything Personally

Oh, this one is HUGE.

If you’ve read my blog about salon culture, you know I’ve talked about spending the early years of Urban Betty walking on eggshells around certain people. I was terrified of confrontation and didn’t have the confidence to have difficult conversations.

And one of the biggest red flags I’ve learned to recognize is when you feel like you can’t give someone feedback without them becoming defensive, shutting down, or turning the entire conversation into something personal.

Now, I want to be very clear about something. I don’t expect anyone to jump for joy when they’re receiving constructive criticism. I certainly don’t!

I’ve spent years in therapy working on my own reactions to feedback, and I can still get triggered when someone tells me something I don’t necessarily want to hear.

Sometimes I need a minute to process it. Sometimes I need to think about it overnight. And sometimes I come back and realize, you know what? They were right.

And sometimes they weren’t!

But that’s the whole point. Being able to receive feedback doesn’t mean automatically agreeing with everything someone says. It means being willing to listen, reflect, and have a productive conversation about it.

I’ve worked with people who initially got upset about feedback but came back later with a completely different perspective. That is a HUGE green flag to me because it shows self-awareness and a willingness to grow.

On the other hand, when someone consistently refuses to take accountability, views every correction as a personal attack, or makes themselves the victim in every situation, it becomes incredibly difficult to move forward.

You can provide all the education, coaching, and support in the world, but ultimately, you cannot force another human being to change.

One of the most valuable things my therapist taught me is that I cannot control the conditions of another person. I can set expectations, communicate clearly, provide opportunities, and hold people accountable. But I cannot control how someone chooses to respond.

And that realization has made me a much better leader.

 

The People Who Stay Don’t Just Identify Problems. They Solve Them.

When I think about our longest-tenured Urban Betty employees, there’s something they all seem to have in common.

They’re problem solvers.

They don’t completely fall apart when something goes wrong. They adapt, figure things out, and often step into responsibilities that weren’t necessarily part of their original job description.

I once heard someone describe the difference between employees in terms of levels of problem-solving. At the lowest level, someone simply identifies a problem and complains about it. At the highest level, someone notices the problem, figures out a solution, and comes to you to explain what they’ve already done.

I LOVE that.

Think about how different those two people are to manage.

One person walks into your office every day with a list of things that aren’t working. The other walks in and says, “Hey, I noticed this wasn’t working, so here’s what I did to fix it.”

Which one would you want helping run your company?

Our CEO, Hallie, is a perfect example of this. She’s been with Urban Betty for 17 years and started at our front desk in 2009. Long before she became CEO, she was already stepping into responsibilities beyond her job description.

She was constantly asking questions like, “What else can I do? How does this work? Can you teach me that?”

She didn’t wait for someone to hand her a leadership title before she started behaving like a leader.

Over the years, she continued learning, taking on more responsibilities, and growing alongside the business. And eventually, she became the person leading the company.

That’s what I mean when I talk about finding great long-term employees.

Sometimes the person standing at your front desk today is the person who could be running your company 15 years from now.

But you have to create an environment where those people can grow.

 

How Our Hiring Process Has Changed Over 20 Years

I mentioned earlier that when I opened Urban Betty, my hiring process was essentially finding people who could pay booth rent.

As the business transitioned to a commission model, I started conducting one-on-one interviews myself. Eventually, we developed a much more extensive hiring process that included phone screenings, DISC personality assessments, manager interviews, peer interviews, and practical model demonstrations for stylists.

Over the years, we’ve continued refining that process because I’ve learned that more steps don’t necessarily mean better hiring decisions.

Today, we typically start with a Zoom interview with the location manager. If that goes well, the candidate comes in for an in-person peer interview with two of our stylists. For stylist positions, the next step is a practical demonstration where they work on a model so we can evaluate their technical abilities.

For front desk positions, our front desk leads, assistant managers, and location managers are involved in the interview process.

We also conduct background checks as part of our hiring process, using appropriate screening procedures.

And here’s something else I love about involving our team in hiring. Sometimes I’ll meet someone and think they’re absolutely amazing, but another employee will have a completely different impression.

That doesn’t mean either person is necessarily wrong. It just gives us a broader perspective.

When you let candidates talk to people who actually work in your business, they get a much better understanding of your culture, too. They can ask honest questions about what it’s like to work there rather than only hearing the owner’s perspective.

It’s a two-way street. We’re interviewing them, but they should also be figuring out whether Urban Betty is somewhere they genuinely want to work.

And that’s important because hiring someone who isn’t happy in your environment isn’t good for anyone.

 

The $20,000 Hiring Lesson I’ll Never Forget

Even with all the experience I’ve gained, I can tell you that you never truly know everything about someone you’re hiring.

One of the most difficult lessons we learned involved an employee who started at our front desk and eventually moved into our associate program.

They were great in both roles, and from what we could see, everything seemed to be going well.

Until cash started disappearing.

At first, we thought there were mistakes in the financial reports. People miscount cash sometimes, and we didn’t immediately assume anything more serious was happening.

But the discrepancies continued, and eventually we reviewed our systems and security footage and discovered that this employee had been stealing from the salon.

By the time everything was uncovered, approximately $20,000 had gone missing.

And here’s the part that still gets me. Afterward, we searched this person’s name online and discovered that there were already publicly available records involving previous theft-related arrests.

We hadn’t done that research before hiring them.

That was a painful lesson for me as a business owner, and it completely changed how we approached hiring and internal safeguards.

Today, background checks are part of our process, and we take financial controls and accountability much more seriously. A background check isn’t a guarantee that someone will be a good employee, but it’s one more tool that can help us make informed decisions.

What I learned from that situation is that you can’t rely entirely on someone making a great impression.

You need systems that protect your business, your employees, and your guests.

And sometimes, unfortunately, the most expensive lessons are the ones that change how you operate forever.

You Can’t Predict Everything, but You Can Set People Up for Success

Here’s something I think is really important to acknowledge.

After more than 20 years of hiring, I still get surprised.

I’ve hired people who I thought would be with Urban Betty forever, and they ended up leaving much sooner than I expected. And I’ve seen stylists who I worried might struggle once they got onto the floor turn into incredible, successful professionals.

You just never know.

But what you CAN control is the environment you create for them once they’re hired.

At Urban Betty, we have a group of experienced educators who train our associates and help prepare them to become stylists. These are people who’ve spent years working within our company, understand our standards, and know what it takes to succeed.

They’re not just teaching technical skills. They’re also passing along the culture and expectations that make Urban Betty what it is.

And even when we hire experienced stylists who don’t need to complete our associate program, we typically pair them with another stylist for a brief mentorship period of about two weeks.

That gives them someone they can go to with questions, someone who understands the systems, and someone who can help them feel comfortable in a new environment.

I think that’s incredibly important because starting at a new salon can be overwhelming, even when you’ve been doing hair for years.

Every company operates differently, and having someone to help you navigate those first few weeks can make a huge difference.

The Biggest Hiring Mistake Salon Owners Make

If I had to name the biggest hiring mistake I’ve seen in our industry, it would be hiring out of desperation.

And believe me, I get it.

Our industry can be incredibly challenging when it comes to staffing. Hairstylists move around. People change salons, move cities, go independent, or decide they want to do something completely different.

When you’re trying to grow your business and you have empty chairs, it can feel like you need to hire anyone who shows interest.

I’ve been there.

You meet someone, they’re licensed, they seem nice enough, and you’re already imagining how much revenue they’ll bring into the salon.

But that’s exactly when you need to slow down.

Because hiring the wrong person just to fill a chair can cost you so much more than leaving that chair empty a little longer.

It can affect your guests, your existing team, your culture, your managers’ time, and ultimately your profitability.

The more we’ve refined our hiring process at Urban Betty, the more selective we’ve been able to become. And that doesn’t mean we’re looking for perfect people. There is no such thing.

We’re looking for people who want to be part of what we’re building, who are open to learning, and who share the values that matter to our team.

And sometimes that means saying no to someone who might be incredibly talented.

 

Trust Your Gut, but Don’t Skip the Process

If I could give a salon owner one piece of advice before they make their next hire, it would be to pay attention to their intuition.

I’ve ignored my gut plenty of times over the years, and more often than not, I’ve regretted it.

You know that feeling when you’re interviewing someone and everything looks fine on paper, but something just doesn’t feel right?

Don’t automatically ignore it because you really need another stylist.

Take a moment to figure out WHY you’re feeling that way. Is there something about their communication? Their attitude toward feedback? Their punctuality? Something inconsistent between what they’re saying and how they’re showing up?

Look for actual behaviors that support your concern, ask more questions, and use the same fair hiring standards for everyone.

Sometimes your intuition is telling you to pay closer attention, and that’s worth listening to.

I also love the saying, “Hire slow, fire fast.”

It’s funny because in the salon industry, we tend to do the exact opposite. We hire fast because we’re desperate for people, and then we take forever to let someone go because we’re terrified of losing the revenue they’re producing.

I’ve made both of those mistakes.

Over time, I’ve learned that hiring thoughtfully and addressing serious performance issues promptly, with clear expectations and fair opportunities to improve, is much healthier for everyone involved.

The right people won’t necessarily be perfect when they walk through your doors. But they’ll be willing to learn, take feedback, ask questions, and grow with you.

And those are the people who help you build something really special.

 

What 20 Years of Hiring Has Taught Me

When I look at Urban Betty today, one of the things I’m proudest of isn’t our revenue, our awards, or even how many locations we’ve opened.

It’s the people.

It’s the stylists who’ve built entire careers with us. It’s the assistants who grew into successful professionals. It’s the front desk employees who became managers. And it’s people like Hallie, who started at the front desk and eventually became CEO.

None of that happened because I magically knew how to hire the right people when I opened my salon at 27.

It happened because I made mistakes, learned from them, refined our systems, and gradually became more intentional about the kind of company I wanted to build.

And I’m still learning.

I still get hiring decisions wrong sometimes. I still have moments when someone surprises me. And I still have to remind myself not to rush the process just because there’s an empty chair.

But if there’s one thing I’ve learned, it’s that technical talent might get someone in the door, but character, curiosity, accountability, and connection are what help them build a lasting career.

You can teach someone to do beautiful hair.

You can teach someone your systems.

But building a great team starts with finding people who genuinely want to learn, contribute, and grow alongside you.

And when you find those people, invest in them.

Because the person you’re interviewing today might be the person who helps build your business for the next 20 years.

 

Let’s Talk About Building Your Team

If you’re a salon owner who’s struggling with hiring, retaining employees, developing leaders, or figuring out how to build a team that doesn’t depend entirely on you, I’d love to connect.

I’ve spent more than 20 years building Urban Betty, and I’ve learned a lot through trial and error. I’m not here to pretend I have all the answers, but I’m always happy to share what’s worked for us, what hasn’t, and what I wish I’d known when I was starting out.

You can book a one-hour call with me, and we can talk through your hiring process, your team challenges, and whatever you’re working toward in your business.

No gatekeeping. Just real conversations and lessons learned from building a multimillion-dollar salon company.

Book a One-Hour Call With Me

Because building a successful salon isn’t just about filling chairs. It’s about finding the right people to help you build something that lasts.